Variable Annuity Pros and Cons: A Comprehensive Overview

Fact-Checked | View our Editorial Guidelines

Variable annuities are a popular investment option for individuals seeking to secure their financial future, particularly during retirement. These annuity contracts allow investors to earn higher returns by allocating funds to various underlying investment portfolios. As with any investment product, there are advantages and disadvantages to consider when evaluating whether a variable annuity is the right choice for your specific financial goals and risk tolerance.

The main benefit of variable annuities is the possibility of earning higher returns than fixed annuities and other more conservative investment options. This is primarily because a variable annuity’s value depends on the performance of the underlying portfolios designated by the contractholder, providing greater growth potential. However, along with higher growth potential comes increased risk, as the annuity’s value can also decrease if the underlying investments perform poorly. Additionally, variable annuities are more complex and may have higher fees than other products.

Before deciding whether a variable annuity is the right choice for you, evaluating the potential benefits and drawbacks is crucial. Understanding the complexities of variable annuities and their role in creating a well-rounded retirement strategy can help you make a more informed decision that aligns with your long-term financial objectives.

Burial Insurance
Know Your Rate
Contact info NOT required.

Key Takeaways

  • Variable annuities offer higher growth potential compared to other annuity products.
  • Increased risk and potential for loss must be considered when investing in variable annuities.
  • Before committing to this investment option, assessing the complexities and fees associated with variable annuities is crucial.

Understanding Variable Annuities

Variable annuities are a type of annuity contract that allows investors to grow their money on a tax-deferred basis by allocating it among a collection of investment vehicles, known as sub-accounts. The value of a variable annuity can fluctuate based on the performance of these investment options.

Variable Versus Fixed Annuities

Fixed Annuities

A fixed annuity is an insurance contract that guarantees a specific, predetermined interest rate on the principal invested and typically ensures a fixed stream of payments to the annuitant for a set period or life.

  • Pros: Fixed interest and predictable income stream, safe and secure investment, tax-deferred growth
  • Cons: Limited growth potential, may not keep up with inflation, potential for high fees and surrender charges, can be less flexible than other investment options

Variable Annuities

A variable annuity, on the other hand, allows investors to allocate their money among various investment options, typically mutual fund-like sub-accounts, with the potential for higher returns based on the performance of those investments.

  • Pros: Potential for higher returns, multiple investment options, tax-deferred growth, ability to receive guaranteed income or a death benefit (additional fees may apply)
  • Cons: Increased risk due to the fluctuating value, potential for high fees and surrender charges, complexities, and management fees associated with the chosen investment options

When comparing variable and fixed annuities, investors must consider their risk tolerance, investment objectives, and time horizon. A fixed annuity might be more suitable if the investor seeks safety and predictability, while a variable annuity could be a better fit for investors looking to potentially earn higher returns and grow their assets over time.

It’s essential to thoroughly understand the features, fees, and performance of the chosen annuity product and consult a financial professional to ensure that it aligns with your financial goals and needs.

Pros of Variable Annuities

Income Stream

Variable annuities offer a diversified income stream, which appeals to those seeking retirement income. Investors can select from various investment portfolios, allocating money to sub-accounts based on risk tolerance and financial goals. Over time, these investments can grow and generate an income stream for retirement. The income is not guaranteed. Nevertheless, it can outlive the initial investments when the underlying funds perform well.

Tax Benefits

One of the significant advantages of variable annuities is their tax-deferred growth. Investment earnings are not subject to income tax while they remain in the annuity account. Additionally, money in a variable annuity can be moved from one investment option to another without triggering taxes. This flexibility allows investors to adjust their investment strategies over time without incurring immediate tax consequences. Remember that tax-deferred status does not mean tax-free; taxes must be paid on the earnings upon withdrawal.

Death Benefits

Variable annuities commonly include a death benefit feature. If the annuity owner passes away, the designated beneficiary is entitled to receive a guaranteed amount, typically no less than the original amount invested minus withdrawals. Some annuity contracts may offer enhanced death benefits that can increase based on investment performance. This feature provides a financial safety net for the beneficiary and ensures that the annuity owner’s investment is not lost entirely when they pass away. Remember that death benefits are subject to the insurer’s terms and conditions and may not be applicable in all cases.

Burial Insurance
Know Your Rate
Contact info NOT required.

Cons of Variable Annuities

Fees and Expenses

Variable annuities often come with various fees and expenses that can significantly affect an investor’s return. Some common fees associated with these financial products include:

  • Investment management fees: These are charged for managing the underlying investments within the separate account.
  • Mortality and expense risk charges: An annual fee for the cost of providing a lifetime income guarantee, which is a primary feature of annuities.
  • Administrative fees: Charges for the ongoing administration of the annuity contract.
  • Surrender fees: If an investor decides to withdraw their money from a variable annuity within a certain period after purchasing the contract, they may be subject to surrender fees.
  • Sales commissions: Financial advisors may earn commissions for selling variable annuity products, which can affect the overall cost of the annuity.

These fees and expenses can substantially reduce the potential return on a variable annuity investment, thus limiting its attractiveness to investors.

Risk Factors

Variable annuities are subject to various risks that can impact the performance of the investment. Some of these risk factors include:

  • Market risk: The value of the investments in the separate account can fluctuate due to changes in the financial markets, which may affect the annuity’s payout and overall value.
  • Interest rate risk: As interest rates change, the value of the investments in the separate account could decline, making it difficult for the annuity holder to achieve desired returns.
  • Inflation risk: Over time, inflation can erode the real value of the income received from a variable annuity, especially if the returns do not keep pace with the rising cost of living.
  • Company risk: The financial health of the insurance company issuing the variable annuity can also impact the annuity’s value, as the insurer is responsible for meeting the payout commitments.

These risks can make variable annuities more complex and difficult to manage than other investment options, such as fixed annuities or bonds.

Withdrawal Limitations

Variable annuities often have withdrawal limitations that can be inconvenient for investors. Some of these restrictions include:

  • Surrender charges: As mentioned earlier, withdrawing funds from a variable annuity contract before the specified time period can result in surrender fees, which can be a financial burden.
  • Age restrictions: Some contracts may have age-related restrictions on withdrawals, such as a requirement to wait until a certain age (e.g., 59 ½) before making penalty-free withdrawals.
  • Early withdrawal penalties: Besides surrender fees and age restrictions, investors may face early withdrawal penalties if they access their funds before the specified time period.

These withdrawal limitations can make variable annuities a less flexible investment choice, particularly for those needing access to their funds in the short term or case of emergencies.

Variable Annuities and Retirement

Variable annuities allow investors to accumulate a retirement nest egg on a tax-deferred basis, meaning taxes are not due until withdrawals are made. These financial products have both advantages and disadvantages when it comes to retirement planning. In this section, we will discuss the role of variable annuities in retirement plans.

Annuities in Retirement Plans

When considering variable annuities as part of a retirement plan, weighing their pros and cons is essential.

Pros of Variable Annuities:

  • Tax-Deferred Growth: Earnings in a variable annuity grow tax-deferred until withdrawal, allowing the investment to compound more rapidly than taxable investments.
  • Lifetime Income: Variable annuities can provide a guaranteed lifetime income stream, ensuring the retiree does not outlive their assets.
  • Investment Options: Variable annuities offer various sub-accounts, giving investors flexibility and control over their underlying investments.
  • Death Benefit: Most variable annuities include a death benefit feature that ensures the annuity holder’s beneficiaries receive a minimum payout in case of the holder’s death.

Cons of Variable Annuities:

  • Fees: Variable annuities often come with high fees, including management, mortality and expense risk fees, and surrender charges.
  • Complexity: Variable annuities can be complex and difficult to understand, making it challenging for some investors to make informed decisions.
  • Taxation: Withdrawals from variable annuities are taxed as ordinary income, which can be higher than the long-term capital gains tax rate on other investments.
  • Limited Access to Funds: Early withdrawals from variable annuities may be subject to surrender charges and a 10% IRS penalty if taken before the age of 59½.

Variable annuities can be an effective component of an individual’s retirement strategy, particularly for those who have already maxed out their contributions to other tax-advantaged retirement accounts such as IRAs or 401(k)s. However, it is important to carefully evaluate the specific variable annuity product, considering the fees, investment options, and overall fit within one’s retirement plan before committing to this type of investment.

In-depth with Variable Annuities

Contrasting Mutual Funds and Variable Annuities

Variable annuities and mutual funds are investment vehicles often used for retirement planning. They both involve pooling funds from investors and spreading the investments across various asset classes. However, there are some key differences between the two:

  • Tax Treatment: Variable annuities offer tax deferral on gains, allowing investors to defer taxes until withdrawals are made. On the other hand, mutual funds are subject to capital gains taxes in the year the gains are realized.
  • Insurance: Variable annuities are insurance contracts providing a death benefit and optional additional insurance riders. Mutual funds do not offer these features.
  • Fees: Both investment options have management and operational fees, but variable annuities tend to have higher fees due to the insurance components.
  • Subaccounts: Variable annuities have subaccounts (similar to mutual funds) where the investments are held, offering various investment options for the annuity holder.
  • Flexibility: Mutual funds offer more flexibility in buying and selling shares, while variable annuities may impose surrender charges and withdrawal restrictions.
FeatureVariable AnnuitiesMutual Funds
Tax TreatmentTax-deferred gainsTaxed upon realizing gains
InsuranceProvides death benefit and ridersNone
FeesTypically higher feesLower fees
Investment OptionsSubaccountsVariety of mutual funds
FlexibilityLess flexible; may have restrictionsFlexible in trading shares
Burial Insurance
Know Your Rate
Contact info NOT required.

Evaluating Insurance Contracts

As mentioned earlier, variable annuities are insurance contracts, distinguishing them from mutual funds and other investments. The insurance aspect brings additional factors to consider when evaluating these contracts:

  • Death Benefit: A key component of variable annuities is the guaranteed death benefit, ensuring that upon the annuity holder’s death, their beneficiaries will receive at least the amount initially invested, minus any withdrawals.
  • Riders: Optional insurance riders can be added to a variable annuity contract to provide additional benefits, such as guaranteed lifetime income, long-term care coverage, or enhanced death benefits. These riders typically come with additional fees.
  • Surrender Charges: Withdrawals made during a certain period (e.g., within the first 5-7 years) of owning the annuity may be subject to surrender charges. These charges are typically a percentage of the withdrawal amount, decreasing over time.
  • Guaranteed Options: Some variable annuities offer guaranteed minimum investment return options, providing a safety net to the investor in case the subaccounts underperform. However, these options usually have higher fees.

When evaluating a variable annuity contract, it is essential to consider these factors, comparing the benefits, fees, and investment options to determine whether this type of investment suits your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Complexities with Variable Annuities

Understanding Surrender Periods and Charges

Variable annuities often have surrender periods, which are time frames during which an investor incurs charges for withdrawing money from the annuity. Surrender periods vary depending on the annuity contract but generally last 5 to 10 years. The surrender charges can be quite high, sometimes up to 10% of the withdrawal amount, and typically decrease over time.

Surrender periods and charges are often associated with deferred variable annuities, where investors receive payments later, allowing their investment to grow tax-deferred. These charges protect insurance companies from investors withdrawing significant funds too early, allowing them to realize investment returns.


Years      | Surrender Charge
1          | 8%
2          | 7%
3          | 6%
4          | 5%
5          | 4%
6+         | 0%

Investors need to understand their annuity’s specific surrender period and the charges associated with early withdrawals. It’s also crucial to note that many annuities allow a certain percentage of withdrawals without surrender charges, usually about 10% per year.

Riders and Other Add-On Options

Variable annuities often offer optional riders (additional contract features) that can enhance the annuity’s performance or provide additional benefits. Some common riders include:

  • Income riders: These riders guarantee a specific income during the annuity’s payout phase, regardless of the annuity’s investment performance.
  • Death Benefit riders: These riders protect beneficiaries in case of the annuitant’s death, ensuring they receive either the amount paid into the annuity or the value at the time of death, whichever is higher.
  • Long-term care riders: These riders provide funds for long-term care expenses if the annuitant cannot perform certain activities of daily living.

These rider options often come with additional costs and can complicate understanding the annuity’s total cost and performance. Therefore, it’s important that investors carefully review potential rider options and the associated fees when considering a variable annuity.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *