Withdrawals, free amounts, and surrender
How MYGA and other deferred annuities handle early access — the free amount, the surrender charge, and what to confirm in your own contract.
The short version
- A deferred annuity isn't locked solid — most contracts let you take roughly 10% out each year with no penalty.
- Take more than that during the surrender period and the carrier applies a charge that's highest in year one and steps down to zero by the end of the term.
- On a partial withdrawal the free amount comes out first; the charge applies only to the excess above it.
- Some contracts add a market value adjustment, and money taken before age 59½ can trigger a separate 10% federal penalty — your own policy pages control the exact numbers.
Every deferred annuity is a written contract, and getting money out of it follows two rules: an amount you can take freely each year, and a charge for taking more than that before the term is up. Neither is a mystery — both are printed in your policy.
The reason early access feels complicated is that the details vary by product, state, and the date you bought. This guide walks through the terms worth knowing, how the free amount and the surrender charge interact, what a partial withdrawal actually costs, and the handful of things to confirm against your own paperwork before you move a dollar.
This is a map, not your contract
Surrender charges, free-withdrawal windows, waivers, and market value adjustments differ by product, state, and issue date. The numbers below are typical patterns — your policy pages and the carrier's current administrative rules are what actually govern your contract.
Terms worth knowing
Four words do most of the work in any conversation about getting money out. Knowing what each one means resolves most of the confusion:
Account / contract value
What the carrier says your contract is worth on a given date, before any early-withdrawal charge is applied. The exact definition differs slightly company to company.
Surrender charge
A percentage fee the insurer may apply when you take out more than the contract allows during the surrender-charge period. It declines each year and ends with the term.
Free-withdrawal amount
A portion you may take each contract year without a surrender charge — if your policy includes the feature and you meet its timing rules.
RMD / qualified money
If the annuity holds IRA or plan dollars, required distributions follow IRS rules separate from the insurer's surrender mechanics. See qualified vs non-qualified.
Free withdrawal allowances
Many multi-year fixed annuities sold to retail savers include a limited annual free withdrawal — often described as roughly 10% of something. That "something" is contract value, premium, or the prior-year balance, and your contract defines which. Some products impose a waiting period (for example, no free withdrawal until after the first contract year); others stack riders or promotions that change the math.
The one thing to confirm before you buy
If you might face a large, unplanned cash need inside the guarantee period, confirm how much can leave in a single year without a surrender charge — and whether unused allowance carries forward to the next year. Many contracts don't let it carry forward.
Surrender schedules
During the initial rate-guarantee period, insurers typically publish a declining surrender schedule: a higher percentage early in the term that steps down each year until it reaches zero. The schedule is fixed at issue for that period, and you should receive it in your illustration and policy.
A common shape for a 5-year MYGA looks like this. Yours may differ — read the schedule in your own contract — but the pattern of a high first-year charge stepping down to zero at maturity is typical:
| Contract year | Surrender charge |
|---|---|
| Year 1 | 9% |
| Year 2 | 8% |
| Year 3 | 7% |
| Year 4 | 6% |
| Year 5 | 5% |
| Year 6+ (after the term) | 0% |
Illustrative schedule only. The charge applies to amounts withdrawn above any free-withdrawal allowance during the surrender period; once the term ends, it typically drops to zero.
The charge steps down to zeroA typical 5-year MYGA surrender schedule — highest in year one, gone at maturity.
Renewal or subsequent guarantee segments can reset or change the schedule. Read what happens at the end of the term — the renewal rate band, any new surrender period — before you count on the cash being freely movable on a specific date.
Partial withdrawal vs full surrender
A partial withdrawal takes less than the full contract value. The carrier applies the free-amount rules first, then may apply surrender charges only to the excess above that — exactly how depends on the policy. A full surrender closes the contract: charges, plus any market value adjustment, apply to the balance per the policy, and you receive the net proceeds on the carrier's settlement timeline.
Here's how the "free amount first, charge the excess" rule typically plays out when you need $30,000 out of a $100,000 contract in year 2, with a 10% free-withdrawal allowance and an 8% year-2 surrender charge:
Illustrative only. Your contract defines what the 10% is measured against, whether a market value adjustment also applies, and how tax hits the gain portion. Withdrawals before age 59½ may add a 10% federal penalty on the taxable amount.
Systematic withdrawals (scheduled payments) and annuitization convert the contract into an income stream with different tax and charge rules — don't assume they behave like a one-time partial withdrawal.
Market value adjustment (MVA)
Some contracts add a market value adjustment on certain withdrawals before maturity. It can increase or decrease what you receive, depending on how interest rates have moved since you bought and the formula written into your policy. If your disclosure mentions an MVA, read our MVA overview next.
Taxes, penalties, beneficiaries
How a withdrawal is taxed depends on where the money came from — and a separate federal penalty can apply if you take it too early. The two cases differ in what you owe:
Non-qualified (after-tax)
Withdrawals are generally taxed on the gain first — the growth is treated as coming out ahead of your original principal. Only the gain portion is taxable.
Qualified (IRA / plan)
Distributions are generally taxed as ordinary income in the year you take them, since the dollars went in pre-tax.
The 59½ rule can stack a second cost
Withdrawals before age 59½ may trigger a federal — and sometimes state — penalty on the taxable portion, on top of any surrender charge, unless an exception applies. Death-benefit and beneficiary options are contract-specific. For a structured overview see qualified vs non-qualified; for advice on a specific move, talk with your CPA.
When in doubt, check these
Most surprises on an early withdrawal come from a number nobody looked up first. Before you act, confirm the specifics for your own contract:
Open your policy and your most recent annual statement — the surrender percentages are often printed there.
Call the carrier's policyholder service line and ask for a written illustration of a hypothetical withdrawal on a date you specify.
Confirm whether a market value adjustment applies to your contract, and whether your money is qualified or non-qualified before you move it.
Weighing an early exit against a better offer?
If you're thinking about breaking a current contract to chase a higher rate, line up today's MYGA and CD rates side by side first — compare live rates → before you decide the surrender charge is worth it.
Frequently asked questions
Can I take any money out before the term ends?
Usually yes. Most multi-year fixed annuities include a free-withdrawal allowance — often around 10% of value each contract year — that you can take with no surrender charge. Anything above that during the surrender period is what triggers the charge.
How is the surrender charge calculated?
The carrier applies your free amount first, then multiplies that year's surrender percentage by the excess above it. On a $30,000 withdrawal from a $100,000 contract with a 10% free amount and an 8% charge, the charge is 8% of $20,000 — $1,600. The percentage steps down each year until it reaches zero at maturity.
What's a market value adjustment, and does mine have one?
An MVA is an extra adjustment some contracts apply to early withdrawals; it can raise or lower your proceeds depending on how rates have moved since you bought. Not every contract has one — check your disclosure, then see our MVA overview.
Will I owe a penalty if I'm under 59½?
Possibly. The IRS can add a 10% federal penalty on the taxable portion of a withdrawal taken before age 59½, separate from any surrender charge, unless an exception applies. Confirm your account type and talk with your CPA before moving money.
Thinking about breaking a contract?
Get a free, no-pitch Second Opinion — we’ll estimate what an early exit would cost, check it against the live market, and send you a plain written take. You decide what to do with it.
Get a free Second Opinion →