The 1035 exchange
How to move from an older annuity into a better one without a tax bill — and how to tell whether the switch actually beats the surrender charge.
The short version
- A 1035 exchange moves the cash value of one annuity (or life policy) straight into another and keeps your built-up gain tax-deferred — no tax bill at the time of the swap.
- The money has to move company to company. Take a check yourself and the deferral usually breaks, turning the gain into ordinary income.
- Only like-kind swaps qualify, and the owner and annuitant generally have to stay the same.
- The real question isn't "can I exchange?" — it's whether a higher new rate clears the surrender charge you'd pay to leave the old contract. That's arithmetic, and it's worth doing before you move.
A 1035 exchange — named after the section of the Internal Revenue Code that allows it — lets you swap one annuity for a better one without triggering a tax bill on the gain you've already earned. It's how savers move from an older, lower-rate contract into a current one while keeping the tax clock running.
That last part is the whole point. Cash out an annuity and reinvest, and the IRS taxes your gain as ordinary income the year you take the money. A 1035 lets the same dollars land in a new contract with the deferral intact. But the rules are specific, and the math of whether to switch matters more than the mechanics of how.
This guide covers what qualifies, how the gain is taxed, the surrender-charge break-even that decides whether a move pays off, the steps a clean transfer takes, the questions to ask before you sign, and where GetSure fits.
What a 1035 exchange actually is
A 1035 exchange replaces an existing qualifying annuity or life-insurance policy with another qualifying contract — without recognizing tax on the gain at the time of the swap, as long as the transaction is a direct exchange that meets the rules. Two ideas do most of the work:
Deferral stays intact
The gain inside your old contract isn't taxed at the swap. Tax deferral simply continues in the new policy — which is the entire reason to use a 1035 instead of cashing out and starting over.
No "constructive receipt"
If the cash ever lands in your hands or your bank account — even briefly — the exchange usually breaks and the gain becomes taxable income. The transfer has to flow directly between the two insurers.
Typically the policy owner and the annuitant (or insured) must stay the same; changing those parties usually starts a new tax story. And some products — many income annuities once they're irrevocably issued — simply can't be moved by 1035 at all. Both the surrendering carrier's contract language and the IRS rules have to line up.
What can be exchanged for what
Section 1035 only covers like-kind replacements. The categories are narrow, and the one most people get wrong is the annuity-to-life direction — it's a one-way street.
| From | To | Qualifies? |
|---|---|---|
| Non-qualified annuity | Non-qualified annuity | Yes |
| Life insurance | Life insurance | Yes |
| Life insurance | Non-qualified annuity | Yes |
| Non-qualified annuity | Qualified long-term care insurance | Yes |
| Non-qualified annuity | Life insurance | No |
Simplified. Certain endowment swaps within statutory limits can also qualify — confirm current law and the carriers' own rules with a tax advisor.
An annuity can fund long-term care coverage tax-free
Since 2010, the Pension Protection Act lets you 1035-exchange a non-qualified annuity directly into a tax-qualified long-term care insurance contract — including the LTC side of a hybrid annuity. The gain that would otherwise be taxable on the way out moves over untaxed, and qualified LTC benefits later come out tax-free. It's one of the few ways to repurpose an annuity you no longer need for income.
Qualified money plays by different rules
IRA and 401(k) dollars don't move by 1035 — they follow rollover and transfer rules instead. Don't assume the mechanics here apply to retirement-account money. See qualified vs non-qualified.
The real question: does switching beat the surrender charge?
A 1035 keeps the IRS out of it, but it doesn't make the old carrier's surrender charge disappear. If you leave a contract mid-term, that penalty comes out of your balance before the rest gets reinvested. So the move only pays off when the new rate earns back the charge and then some over the time you'll hold the new contract.
Here's that arithmetic on a $100,000 contract. You're paying a 4% surrender charge to leave a 4.00% contract for a 4.75% one, and planning to hold the new policy five years:
Illustrative, compounded annually. In this case the 4% charge eats nearly the whole rate advantage — staying put wins by a hair. Push the new rate higher, the term longer, or the surrender charge lower, and the verdict flips. The point is to run your numbers, not assume a higher rate always wins.
The lever that moves this most is the surrender schedule itself, which steps down each year. Waiting a year or two until the charge has rolled off can turn a losing switch into an obvious one. To see real new rates worth comparing against, check this week's MYGA marketplace.
Why timing the old contract matters
Most deferred annuities carry a surrender schedule: a penalty that's highest in year one and declines every year until it hits zero at the end of the term. Where you sit on that schedule is usually the single biggest factor in whether an exchange makes sense.
A typical 7-year surrender scheduleThe penalty on leaving early declines each year, then disappears — at which point a 1035 costs you nothing to make.
Two situations make the math easy. A contract at or near maturity usually has no surrender cost left — a 1035 there is close to free. And many MYGAs past their initial guarantee period, or sitting in a renewal window, have little or no charge to leave. Read the statement and the schedule; don't guess at where you are.
Don't forget the new contract's surrender terms
A replacement usually starts a fresh surrender period of its own. Make sure you're comfortable tying that money up again, and that the new policy's free-withdrawal rules, riders, and any market-value adjustment match how you'll actually use the money.
How the gain is taxed
Done right, a 1035 is tax-neutral at the moment of the swap. The places it can go wrong are all about how the money moves and what your cost basis does.
Deferred gain. Done correctly, you don't owe tax on the gain in the old contract at the swap — deferral simply continues in the new policy.
Direct transfer. The funds move company to company on the exchange paperwork — never to your bank account first.
Cashing out instead. Taking a distribution generally taxes the gain as ordinary income that year, with a possible 10% penalty on some annuity withdrawals before age 59½.
Basis carries over. Your original cost basis follows into the new contract, so future taxation still refers back to what you actually paid in — it doesn't reset to zero.
Basis can be worth more than the account value
Say you put $100,000 of premium into a non-qualified annuity and the value later sits at $90,000. A proper 1035 can move that position to a new insurer while preserving your $100,000 basis for future gain-and-loss accounting — rather than cashing out and starting over. Confirm the specifics with your tax advisor; this isn't individualized tax advice.
What an exchange costs
There's no separate IRS "1035 filing fee." The costs are the ones already baked into the two contracts:
On the old contract
Surrender charges still apply in an exchange if you're inside the schedule. A same-company product swap sometimes waives them — worth asking the ceding insurer before you look elsewhere.
On the new contract
Rider charges, index spreads on a fixed indexed annuity, and the fresh surrender period. These reduce net yield, so compare after-cost outcomes, not headline rates.
How a clean transfer goes
A 1035 means coordinating two insurers, each with its own forms and timelines. The order matters — start the old carrier's paperwork too late and you can forfeit yield while mail moves.
The five stepsFrom deciding to the receiving carrier confirming the old contract is closed out.
Before you start, pull these together from the existing contract — they make every step faster: the legal carrier and product names, the policy number and recent statements, the surrender-charge schedule and current account value, and any riders, income or death-benefit options, and maturity or renewal terms.
What to ask before you exchange
Most exchanges that go sideways do so because one of these went unasked. Run this list against both contracts before any paperwork is signed — the answers decide whether the move is worth making and how clean the transfer will be.
What's my surrender charge today, in dollars? Ask the ceding carrier for the exact figure as of this month, not the schedule percentage. That number is the hurdle the new rate has to clear.
Is there a market-value adjustment? Many MYGAs add or subtract an MVA on early exit that's separate from the surrender charge. It can swing the payout either way depending on where rates have moved.
What's my cost basis? Get the premium-paid figure on record so it carries over correctly — it matters most when the contract is worth less than you put in.
Am I giving up a rider I'm using? An income or enhanced death-benefit rider you're relying on doesn't follow the money. Confirm the new contract either replaces it or that you no longer need it.
What's the new contract's surrender period and free-withdrawal allowance? You're starting a fresh lock-up. Make sure its term and its annual penalty-free withdrawal limit fit when you'll actually want the money.
How do the two carriers' financial-strength ratings compare? A guarantee is only as good as the insurer behind it. Don't move to a materially weaker carrier for a few extra basis points.
Don't trade strength for a rate
Fixed and income guarantees rest entirely on the issuing carrier's claims-paying ability. A higher advertised rate from a materially weaker insurer isn't automatically a better deal — you'd be swapping safety for yield. Compare the financial-strength rating of both the old and new carriers before you move.
Where GetSure sets the floor
Our marketplace shows fixed deferred contracts from carriers rated A− or better by AM Best. So when you're comparing a new rate to your old contract, the new side already clears a strength bar — you're choosing on rate and terms, not on whether the carrier is sound.
Rules and common questions
Can I do a partial 1035?
Sometimes. The IRS allows partial 1035 treatment in certain fact patterns, but the surrendering company has to cooperate and the basis is split between the two contracts in proportion to value. One trap: under the IRS safe harbor, taking a withdrawal from either contract within 180 days of a partial exchange can cause the IRS to re-test the whole transaction and tax it. Involve a tax professional before attempting a partial.
How long does a 1035 exchange take?
Usually a few weeks, occasionally longer. The receiving carrier sends the exchange request to the ceding carrier, which liquidates and wires the funds. Timing depends on the old insurer's processing speed and whether the contract is past any required notice window. Start the paperwork early so you're not sitting in cash while the transfer clears.
Is there a free-look period on the new contract?
Yes. Most states give you a free-look window — commonly 10 to 30 days after the new contract is issued — to review it and cancel for a refund. On a replacement, many states extend it. Read the new contract during that window and confirm the riders, surrender schedule, and rate match what you were shown.
Can I change the owner or annuitant during the exchange?
Generally no. Ownership continuity is part of what makes the exchange qualify — changing the owner or annuitant just to do the swap typically defeats the 1035 treatment.
Can I combine several old contracts into one new one?
Yes — multiple old contracts can often roll into a single new contract. Going the other way, splitting one old contract into several new ones, is usually not allowed under 1035. Structure matters.
Is the higher rate always worth switching for?
No. A surrender charge on the old contract can erase the gain from a higher new rate, especially over a short hold. Run the break-even on your own numbers — and if you're early in the schedule, waiting until the charge rolls off is often the better move.
A note on guarantees
Guarantees rest on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer. Annuities are not FDIC- or NCUA-insured. This page is educational, not a recommendation to replace any policy or tax advice — state replacement and suitability rules apply to many exchanges, and your tax advisor and both carriers' servicing teams stay essential to a clean transfer.
Wondering if your old annuity is worth keeping?
Get a free, no-pitch Second Opinion — we’ll run the break-even on your current contract against the live market and send you a plain written take. You decide what to do with it.
Get a free Second Opinion →